VCB Secondary Circuit Basics: Trip/Close, Anti-Pumping, Interlocks — OEM Engineering View

Circuit breaker primary circuits carry load and fault currents. Secondary circuits control when those operations happen. A vacuum circuit breaker’s main contacts might withstand 25 kA short-circuit current perfectly—yet the installation fails commissioning because the control wiring introduces nuisance trips, allows dangerous simultaneous closures, or permits motor pumping that destroys the mechanism.

Secondary circuit design separates properly engineered switchgear from field failures waiting to happen. The difference shows up in control logic details: trip coil supervision, anti-pumping relay placement, mechanical interlock verification, and auxiliary contact sequencing.

This guide breaks down VCB secondary circuits from the manufacturer’s engineering perspective. You’ll understand why certain circuit elements exist, how they prevent common failure modes, and what to verify during factory acceptance tests and site commissioning.

What Secondary Circuits Do in Vacuum Circuit Breakers

Primary circuits in a VCB conduct current from line side to load side through the vacuum interrupter contacts. Secondary circuits command those contacts to open or close, prevent improper operations, and report breaker status back to protection relays or SCADA systems.

Secondary circuits encompass:

Control circuits — Trip coil, close coil, spring charging motor circuits that directly actuate the mechanism
Auxiliary circuits — Status indication contacts, position signaling to interlocks and protection devices
Protection circuits — Anti-pumping logic, coil supervision, electrical/mechanical interlock circuits
Annunciation circuits — Alarms for motor failure, spring not charged, mechanism malfunction

Voltage levels vary by application. Most medium-voltage VCBs use 110 VDC or 220 VDC control power from station batteries. Some industrial installations specify 110 VAC or 220 VAC control. The circuit topology stays conceptually similar, though AC control introduces timing considerations around zero-crossing and requires different anti-pumping approaches.

[DESIGN NOTE: DC control allows operation during grid blackouts when station batteries provide backup power—critical for utility breakers protecting generators and transformers]

Understanding secondary circuits starts with the operating sequence. The vacuum circuit breaker working principle explained at https://xbrele.com/what-is-vacuum-circuit-breaker-working-principle/ shows how vacuum arc extinction requires precise contact motion—secondary circuits time and coordinate that motion across all operating conditions.

Trip and Close Circuit Fundamentals

Trip and close circuits directly energize the solenoid coils or motors that actuate the VCB mechanism. Design priorities differ: trip circuits must be fail-safe and ultra-reliable, while close circuits must prevent dangerous simultaneous operations.

Trip Circuit Design

A typical trip circuit follows this signal path:

1. Initiation — Protection relay contact closure, manual trip button, or automatic trip signal
2. Trip coil energization — Current flows through trip coil (typically 5–10 A inrush for DC coils)
3. Mechanism release — Trip latch releases, opening springs drive contacts apart
4. Auxiliary contact operation — “a” contacts open, “b” contacts close to signal breaker status
5. Circuit de-energization — Auxiliary “a” contact in series with trip coil opens, preventing continuous coil energization

The series auxiliary contact prevents trip coil burnout. Without it, the coil remains energized after the breaker trips, overheating and failing within minutes. Proper designs place an “a” (normally open, closed when breaker closed) auxiliary contact in series with the trip coil—when the mechanism trips, this contact opens automatically.

[OEM Design Insight: Trip Circuit Reliability]

• Redundant trip coils (Trip Coil 1 + Trip Coil 2) double reliability for critical applications
• Gold-plated trip coil terminals reduce contact resistance and corrosion failures
• Trip coil continuity supervision alarms alert operators before the breaker can’t trip when needed
• Fast-acting fuses protect trip circuits from short circuits without delaying protection operation

Close Circuit Design

Close circuits charge stored energy (compressed spring or magnetic actuator) then release it to drive contacts closed. Because closing onto a fault creates extreme mechanical stress, close circuits include anti-pumping and interlock protection.

A spring-charged mechanism close sequence:

1. Spring charging — Motor runs until mechanical switch signals “spring charged” (typically 5–15 seconds)
2. Close permissive — Anti-pumping relay and interlocks verify safe-to-close conditions
3. Close coil energization — Close button or automatic close signal energizes close coil
4. Latch release — Close coil releases spring latch, driving contacts closed
5. Auxiliary contact transition — “a” contacts close, “b” contacts open
6. Coil de-energization — Close coil auxiliary contact opens, resetting circuit
7. Spring recharge — Motor automatically recharges spring for next operation

The spring charging motor runs automatically after each close operation or can be manually initiated. A limit switch stops the motor when spring compression reaches the required force. If the motor fails or the spring mechanism jams, the “spring not charged” alarm activates.

Anti-Pumping Circuit Design and Operation

Anti-pumping protection prevents the VCB from repeatedly attempting to close onto a fault. Without it, the breaker cycles open-close-open-close rapidly, destroying the mechanism and potentially causing contact welding.

Why Pumping Occurs

Consider this scenario without anti-pumping:

1. Operator holds close button during a downstream fault
2. Breaker closes
3. Protection relay immediately trips breaker due to fault
4. Close coil remains energized (button still held)
5. Spring recharges automatically
6. Breaker closes again onto the same fault
7. Cycle repeats until mechanism fails or close button releases

This “pumping” action subjects the mechanism to extreme mechanical shock at fault-current making capacity—far exceeding normal duty cycle ratings.

Anti-Pumping Circuit Implementation

A properly designed anti-pumping circuit requires the close command to be reset (de-energized and re-energized) before allowing another close operation:

Control relay method:

• Close coil circuit includes anti-pumping auxiliary relay (52/APR)
• First close command energizes relay, sealing itself in through its own contact
• Relay contact in series with close coil allows closure
• After closing, if breaker trips, the relay remains energized
• Close coil cannot re-energize until operator releases close button (breaking relay seal-in circuit)
• Operator must release then re-press close button for subsequent close attempt

Auxiliary contact method (simpler but less flexible):

• Close coil circuit includes breaker “b” auxiliary contact (closed when breaker open)
• When breaker closes, “b” contact opens, breaking close coil circuit
• Even if close button held, close coil cannot re-energize
• Limitation: Doesn’t prevent pumping on slow reclosing sequences unless combined with relay logic

[Field Failure Case: Anti-Pumping Circuit Bypass]
A mining operation modified their switchgear to allow “forced closure” during emergencies by bypassing anti-pumping protection. During a cable fault, the operator held the close button attempting to restore power. The VCB pumped six times in 15 seconds before the mechanism shattered the spring guide. Replacement cost exceeded $45,000 plus two weeks downtime.

Electrical and Mechanical Interlocks

Interlocks prevent unsafe operating sequences: closing with the earthing switch engaged, operating two incomers simultaneously, or racking the breaker while energized. Implementation uses both hard-wired contacts (electrical interlocks) and physical blocking (mechanical interlocks).

Electrical Interlock Types

Earthing switch interlock:

• Earthing switch “b” contact wired in series with VCB close coil circuit
• When earthing switch closed (grounding the busbar), “b” contact opens
• VCB close circuit cannot energize—prevents closing onto grounded bus
• VCB “b” contact similarly prevents earthing switch closure while breaker closed

Busbar transfer interlock:

• Two incomer VCBs feeding same busbar must not close simultaneously
• Incomer 1 “b” contact wired into Incomer 2 close circuit
• Incomer 2 “b” contact wired into Incomer 1 close circuit
• Only one incomer can close at a time unless bus coupler scheme allows paralleling

Withdrawable breaker interlock:

• “Breaker racked to service position” limit switch contact in close/trip circuits
• Prevents close/trip operations while breaker partially withdrawn
• Reduces arcing risk during contact misalignment

Mechanical Interlock Examples

Key interlock systems:

• Kirk key or castell key physically transfers between devices
• Operator must withdraw key from VCB (proving it’s open) to operate earthing switch
• Key trapped in earthing switch prevents VCB operation until earthing switch opened

Padlock provisions:

• Breaker control panel accepts up to three padlocks
• LOTO (lockout/tagout) compliance for maintenance safety

Racking interlock:

• Physical blocking lever prevents racking breaker into service position if earthing switch closed
• Mechanical override available only with supervisor key

OEM best practice combines all three layers for critical interlocks. For example, earthing switch safety typically requires electrical interlock (auxiliary contacts), mechanical blocking (latch), AND key interlock (sequence enforcement).

Auxiliary Contact Configuration and Sequencing

Auxiliary contacts report breaker position to protection relays, SCADA systems, alarms, and interlock circuits. Contact sequencing—the precise order contacts make and break during opening and closing—determines whether external circuits operate correctly.

Auxiliary Contact Types

“a” contacts (Normally Open):

• Open when breaker open
• Close when breaker closed
• Typical uses: Trip coil circuit, “breaker closed” indication, close permissive for downstream devices

“b” contacts (Normally Closed):

• Close when breaker open
• Open when breaker closed
• Typical uses: Close coil interlock, “breaker open” indication, anti-pumping circuit, earthing switch permissive

Most VCBs provide 6–12 auxiliary contacts as standard, expandable to 20+ with auxiliary contact blocks. Contacts rated 5–10 A at control voltage handle signaling and relay coil loads but cannot directly switch motors or heaters.

Contact Sequencing Requirements

During closing operation:

1. Main contacts approach (no auxiliary transition yet)
2. Main contacts touch (arc strikes if pre-insertion resistor not used)
3. “a” contacts close (typically 5–15 ms after main contact touch)
4. “b” contacts open (typically 10–20 ms after main contact touch)

During opening operation:

1. “b” contacts close (typically 3–10 ms before main contacts separate)
2. “a” contacts open (typically 5–12 ms before main contacts separate)
3. Main contacts separate (arc extinction in vacuum)

This sequencing ensures external circuits see the status change only after the VCB reaches a stable mechanical position. Early “breaker closed” signaling before contacts fully engage can cause protection miscoordination. Late “breaker open” signaling can delay earthing switch permissives, violating safety procedures.

Auxiliary contact timing is verified during VCB type testing. Commissioning checks use simultaneous recording of main contact position and auxiliary contact transitions to confirm proper sequencing.

Control Power Failure and Supervision

Control circuits fail when station batteries discharge, AC control transformers lose supply, or wiring develops high-resistance faults. Secondary circuit design must detect these failures and prevent unsafe conditions.

Trip Circuit Supervision

Continuous trip circuit monitoring ensures the breaker can trip when protection operates:

Supervision relay method:

• Low-current supervision relay connected across trip coil
• Relay energized when trip circuit intact
• Circuit break or coil failure de-energizes relay, triggering alarm
• Does not nuisance-alarm during normal trip operations (relay drop-out faster than alarm pickup)

Microprocessor-based monitoring:

• Protection relay or breaker controller injects test current into trip circuit
• Measures circuit resistance and coil continuity
• Alarms on high resistance or open circuit
• Some systems automatically prevent breaker closing if trip circuit compromised

Spring Charged Supervision

VCBs with spring-operated mechanisms require stored energy to close. If spring motor fails or limit switch malfunctions, the breaker cannot close:

• “Spring not charged” switch contact wired to annunciator
• Alarm alerts operator before close attempt fails
• Some designs prevent close coil energization if spring not charged (hard interlock)

Control Voltage Monitoring

Low control voltage affects coil operation:

• Trip coils may fail to operate below 70% rated voltage
• Close coils exhibit slow, incomplete operation below 80% rated voltage
• Voltage monitoring relays trigger alarms at 85% rated voltage
• Critical breakers may auto-trip on low control voltage to avoid partial-stroke damage

Factory Acceptance and Site Commissioning Verification

Secondary circuits must be verified before site installation. Factory acceptance tests (FAT) and site acceptance tests (SAT) follow overlapping but distinct protocols.

Factory Acceptance Test Checklist

Continuity and insulation:

• Measure resistance between all control terminals
• Verify control circuit insulation >10 MΩ at 500 VDC
• Check that auxiliary contact ratings match specification

Operational sequence:

• Close breaker electrically and verify auxiliary contact transitions
• Trip breaker and confirm series auxiliary contact opens (de-energizing trip coil)
• Measure time between close button press and main contact closure
• Measure time between trip signal and main contact separation

Anti-pumping verification:

• Hold close button, simulate fault trip, confirm single close attempt
• Release and re-press close button, verify second close permitted
• Test with both manual and automatic close signals

Interlock function:

• Verify earthing switch “b” contact prevents VCB close operation
• Confirm VCB “b” contact prevents earthing switch closure
• Test all mechanical key interlocks for proper sequencing

Supervision and alarms:

• Disconnect trip coil lead, verify trip circuit supervision alarm
• Simulate spring motor failure, confirm spring not charged alarm
• Reduce control voltage to 80%, verify under-voltage alarm

Site Commissioning Checklist

Wiring verification:

• Confirm control cable terminations match drawings
• Verify correct polarity for DC control circuits
• Check that remote trip/close signals wire to correct terminals

Integration testing:

• Test protection relay trip signal to VCB
• Verify SCADA open/close commands operate correctly
• Confirm status indication LEDs match actual breaker position

Interlock coordination:

• Test busbar transfer interlock with second breaker installed
• Verify earthing switch interlock operates in both directions
• Confirm all LOTO points accessible and functional

Load testing:

• Close VCB onto actual load (not just no-load testing)
• Verify no nuisance trips under inrush current
• Test trip operation under load (coordination with protection settings)

Site commissioning catches installation errors that factory tests cannot: reversed control polarity, incorrect relay settings, external interlock wiring mistakes, or control power distribution faults.

Common Secondary Circuit Failures and Troubleshooting

Nuisance Trips

Symptoms: Breaker trips without fault present, often during closing operation or motor start

Possible causes:

• Trip circuit insulation breakdown causing leakage current
• Auxiliary contact chatter during mechanical operation
• Control voltage transients from nearby switchgear operations
• Incorrect trip coil rating (too sensitive)

Diagnosis:

• Monitor trip coil current during close operation
• Measure control circuit insulation resistance
• Check auxiliary contact resistance (should be <50 mΩ when closed)

Failed Close Operations

Symptoms: Close button pressed but breaker does not close, or closes sluggishly

Possible causes:

• Spring not charged (motor failure or limit switch misadjustment)
• Low control voltage (<80% rated)
• Interlock contact open (earthing switch, transfer scheme, or racking position)
• Close coil failure or high-resistance connection

Diagnosis:

• Verify “spring charged” indication lamp
• Measure control voltage at close coil terminals during operation
• Temporarily bypass interlock contacts one at a time (restore immediately)
• Measure close coil resistance (compare to nameplate value)

Anti-Pumping Relay Malfunction

Symptoms: Breaker pumps repeatedly on fault, or refuses to close after single trip

Possible causes:

• Anti-pumping relay contact welded closed (allows pumping)
• Relay coil open (prevents any close operation)
• Incorrect wiring of seal-in circuit

Diagnosis:

• Measure relay coil resistance
• Observe relay during close-trip-close sequence (should drop out when close button released)
• Verify seal-in contact continuity during energized state

Auxiliary Contact Sequencing Errors

Symptoms: Protection relay misoperation, SCADA status incorrect, earthing switch interlock fails

Possible causes:

• Auxiliary contact mechanism wear or misalignment
• Contact spring fatigue
• Adjustment shift after mechanical shock or transportation

Diagnosis:

• Record main contact position and auxiliary contact state simultaneously
• Compare timing to manufacturer’s type test data
• Check contact wiper travel and spring tension

Design Considerations for Special Applications

High-Cycle Duty (Mining, EAF)

Frequent operations accelerate auxiliary contact wear:

• Specify gold-plated contacts for longer life
• Use auxiliary contact blocks rated for 100,000+ operations
• Implement contact condition monitoring (resistance trending)

Redundant Protection (Generator, Transformer Protection)

Critical breakers require dual trip coils:

• Each protection relay operates independent trip coil
• Loss of one trip circuit does not compromise protection
• Requires dual supervision relays and independent alarm paths

Remote Operation (Distribution Automation)

SCADA-controlled breakers need additional supervision:

• Breaker position indication must be fail-safe (defaults to “unknown” on control loss)
• Communication loss should not prevent local manual operation
• Implement “select before operate” to prevent inadvertent remote commands

Choosing a VCB Based on Secondary Circuit Design

Secondary circuit quality separates reliable breakers from maintenance burdens. When evaluating suppliers:

Check auxiliary contact ratings: Some manufacturers provide 3 A contacts when application requires 6 A—premature failure results.

Verify anti-pumping implementation: Ask for detailed circuit diagrams showing relay type and seal-in logic.

Examine interlock flexibility: Can the breaker accommodate both electrical and mechanical key interlocks without custom modification?

Review supervision capabilities: Modern designs offer trip circuit supervision, spring status monitoring, and control voltage alarms as standard—older designs require retrofitting.

Confirm FAT test protocol: Does the manufacturer’s standard FAT include anti-pumping verification, contact sequencing measurement, and insulation testing?

XBRELE vacuum circuit breakers include comprehensive secondary circuit packages engineered for reliable operation across utility, industrial, and renewable energy applications. Our standard designs incorporate trip circuit supervision, dual-relay anti-pumping protection, and configurable interlock contact arrangements. Complete secondary circuit documentation, FAT reports, and commissioning support ensure installations meet both safety standards and operational requirements. Learn more about our vacuum circuit breaker product range at https://xbrele.com/vacuum-circuit-breaker-manufacturer/.

Key Takeaways

• Secondary circuits control VCB operation—trip, close, anti-pumping, and interlocks prevent failures primary circuits cannot address
• Trip circuits must be fail-safe with series auxiliary contacts and continuous supervision
• Close circuits require anti-pumping protection to prevent mechanism destruction during fault conditions
• Interlocks combine electrical contacts, mechanical blocking, and administrative controls for safety
• Auxiliary contact sequencing determines whether external systems receive accurate breaker status
• Factory acceptance and site commissioning must verify all secondary circuit functions before energization
• Common failures—nuisance trips, close failures, pumping—trace to inadequate circuit design or poor installation practices

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What is the difference between a trip circuit and a close circuit in a vacuum circuit breaker?
A: Trip circuits energize a coil that releases the mechanism’s trip latch, allowing opening springs to separate the contacts. Close circuits charge stored energy (spring or capacitor) then release it to drive contacts closed. Trip circuits prioritize fail-safe reliability, while close circuits incorporate anti-pumping and interlock protection.

Q2: Why do VCBs need anti-pumping protection?
A: Without anti-pumping protection, a breaker can repeatedly close onto a fault if the close command remains active. This “pumping” action subjects the mechanism to extreme mechanical shock, potentially destroying the spring mechanism or welding contacts. Anti-pumping circuits require the close command to reset before permitting another close attempt.

Q3: How many auxiliary contacts does a typical vacuum circuit breaker provide?
A: Most medium-voltage VCBs include 6–12 auxiliary contacts as standard (mix of “a” normally open and “b” normally closed contacts), expandable to 20+ contacts with additional auxiliary contact blocks. Contacts typically handle 5–10 A at control voltage.

Q4: What is trip circuit supervision and why is it necessary?
A: Trip circuit supervision continuously monitors the integrity of the trip coil circuit using a low-current relay or microprocessor-based system. If the circuit develops an open or high-resistance fault, supervision alarms alert operators before a protection operation fails. This prevents situations where the breaker cannot trip during a fault.

Q5: Can electrical interlocks be bypassed for emergency operations?
A: While physically possible, bypassing electrical interlocks creates severe safety risks and typically violates safety standards. Emergency procedures should use pre-engineered “forced operation” modes with supervisor authorization and additional safeguards—never field modifications that defeat interlocks.

Q6: What happens if control voltage drops below the rated value during operation?
A: Trip coils may fail to operate below 70% rated voltage, while close coils exhibit slow or incomplete operation below 80% rated voltage. Control voltage monitoring relays typically alarm at 85% to provide warning before operational failures occur. Critical applications may auto-trip the breaker on low voltage to avoid partial-stroke damage.

Q7: How is auxiliary contact sequencing verified during commissioning?
A: Commissioning engineers use simultaneous recording of main contact position (via travel measurement) and auxiliary contact state transitions (via logic analyzer or relay test set). Timing measurements are compared to manufacturer’s type test data—typically “a” contacts close 5–15 ms after main contact touch, and “b” contacts close 3–10 ms before main contact separation.

Further Reading

• VCB Working Principle Explained — How vacuum arc physics determines contact operating requirements
• VCB Operating Mechanisms Compared — Spring, magnetic, and electric repulsion mechanism trade-offs
• Commissioning Checklist for VCBs — Field-first acceptance testing protocol
• XBRELE Vacuum Circuit Breaker Manufacturer — Complete VCB product range and technical support